The Gay Butte title was Established during Reign 7.
The title was later made inactive per a proclamation by Reign 16.
The following are the Past Gay Butte Titleholders
| # | Mr. | Ms | Miss |
| 1 (02/03) | William | Dustee Roxanne Love | |
| 2 (03/04) | Robin Love | ||
| 3 (04/05) | Rick | ||
| 4 (05/06) | Beth | ||
| 5 (06/07) | Gina | Tim | |
| 6 (07/08) | Rick | Kaila | |
| 7 (08/09) | Heather | ||
| 8 (09/10) | DWonno | Jenny | |
| 9 (10/11) | Disa Rae | Ginger Shagwell |